Mature Measures: Patricia Fargnoli and
B.H. Fairchild
~EDWARD BYRNE~
MATURE MEASURES:
PATRICIA FARGNOLI
& B.H.
FAIRCHILD
SMALL WISDOMS, LARGE SPIRIT: PATRICIA FARGNOLI'S DUTIES OF THE SPIRIT
The stars continue as far as we know,
as far as we can see, and as far as we can’t.
—Patricia Fargnoli, “Small
Wisdoms”
When Mary Oliver, as judge for Utah State
University Press’s May Swenson Poetry Award, chose Patricia Fargnoli’s
first manuscript of poems, Necessary
Light, to be the 1999 winner, she remarked upon discovery of
this poet "in the winter of her sixtieth year." Oliver observed
how it "is a rarity that is close to an astonishment. For the
authors of first books of poetry — and they are each year in the
hundreds — are almost all young, and they have almost all of them risen
through the same soil: workshops, MFA programs, initial life
experiences. These beginning writers are skillful and hopeful; we
are happy to praise their promise, their new voices, their
energy. Ms. Fargnoli is another case altogether. She is, in
personal and worldly matters if not in issues of publishing, altogether
grown-up." Oliver determined Fargnoli's work contained "poems
absolutely not of promise, but of accomplishment. They are not so
much about excitement and trial as they are about hindsight, wonder,
regret, and rejoicing." She declared: "Authority in poems is
difficult to maintain if it does not come from the writer as well as
the words."
Indeed, Oliver's naming of Patricia Fargnoli as a
first-book award winner was an exceptional choice, but the selection
seemed admirable and appropriate for a number of reasons.
Foremost among them, Fargnoli’s poetry appeared directly descended from
the works of May Swenson and Mary Oliver, as well as additional
distinguished women poets who had written about the relationship
between nature and self with great insight, especially when the subject
of the poem involves experiences of marriage, motherhood, or other
aspects of life viewed from, and enriched by, a distinctly female
perspective. In fact, the strong sense of affinity for nature’s
beauty and grace, combined with a feeling of awe for its mystery and
power, in Fargnoli’s poems may be traced back in an honored line
through the finest works of Elizabeth Bishop, Marianne Moore, and Emily
Dickinson.
In 2004 Patricia Fargnoli produced a second
collection of poems, Small Songs of
Pain (Pecan Grove Press), a book-length sequence of 37 poems
inspired by Marc Chagall’s 1920s paintings portraying LaFontaine’s
fables. Although such an endeavor may seem to have the potential
of being limiting to the poet because of the precise content of the
paintings and the derived context of the fables, wisely Fargnoli often
allowed herself to wander from an objective rendering of the content or
a strict interpretation of the context; instead, she invited readers to
witness inventive personal impressions and innovative flights of
insight arising from a skillful ability to closely observe and openly
imagine the emotions one might attach to such images or the concerns
that might accompany such narratives.
Patricia Fargnoli’s latest book of poetry, Duties of the Spirit (Tupelo Press,
2005), presents a wonderful blending of the characteristics displayed
in her first two collections. The poems in this new volume
continue to demonstrate the shrewd wisdom, generous spirit, and astute
intuition introduced to readers in the mature writings of
Fargnoli’s
first book with the keen observation and free association needed to
assure originality in the second collection. In addition, the
poems show once more Fargnoli’s command of language and careful
crafting of lines. The voice of the poet is reassuring and
welcoming, while at the same time exhibiting vulnerability and
humility.
However, again and again, readers are repeatedly
impressed by
Fargnoli’s refreshing images of nature — the surrounding landscape and
its animal inhabitants, the borders between wilderness and
civilization, or the long course of coastline that separates the
land-locked speakers in the poems from the vast openness of the ocean
before them. Readers are particularly rewarded with poems
revealing instances and experiences where contrasting elements of
different habitats meet or the distinct environments come into
conflict, as well as when an individual resident of one world
trespasses upon another. On just such occasions, Patricia
Fargnoli’s poems resemble most closely similar pieces by Elizabeth
Bishop. Indeed, if a poetic kinship with Fargnoli were to be
determined, Elizabeth Bishop would be a prime candidate.
Marianne Moore, the nearest poetic spirit to
Elizabeth Bishop, once commented in her review of Bishop’s first book, North & South: “Elizabeth
Bishop is spectacular in being unspectacular.” Likewise, Patricia
Fargnoli is at her best when a poem subtly allows observation of the
outer world of nature to be comprehended and complemented by the inner
realizations arrived at naturally by the poet or speaker, small wisdoms
by a writer with a large spirit, rather than forced to fit some
preconceived notion or manipulated by a desire to close the poem with a
clever, but unearned line. As in Bishop’s poetry, there also
exists a persistent sense of loss, or fear of losing, and an elegiac
feeling to many of Fargnoli’s poems as they examine issues of illness
and dying, death or absence, aging and pain, as well as human conflict
or diminishment of nature. Similar to Bishop’s poetry, Fargnoli’s
poems pose questions with an exacting clarity of purpose, yet with a
consistent charity of human kindness.
Like Elizabeth Bishop recalling her own home area of
New England and Nova Scotia, Patricia Fargnoli is most comfortable and
at ease when delivering to readers the landscape and shoreline of her
native New England. Born in Massachusetts and raised by relatives
in Nova Scotia and New England, Bishop attached great emotion to
geography, especially to the settings she remembered from her
childhood. Fargnoli, who lives in New Hampshire, also associates
some of her speakers’ emotional states with the geographical New
England states and the characteristics of their landscape she knows so
well. As in Bishop’s poetry, Fargnoli explores her surroundings,
focusing primarily upon those features where nature and humans,
wilderness and civilization, the real and the imagined seem to merge,
overlap, trespass, or intrude on one another. Jeredith Merrin has
written of Bishop’s attention to “blurred boundaries”: “She seems
always to have been fascinated by what occurs in the liminal state
between consciousness and unconsciousness, waking and sleeping.”
In Patricia Fargnoli’s poems such a blurring of
boundaries or intersection between nature and human supplies
significant imagery. In “Happiness”: “The sheep wander into the
dooryard and eat the grass.” In “From a Clifftop Overlooking
Pigeon Island,” the speaker confides: “The only need I have is this
enclosure, this day / folding around me, / and beyond the cliff, the
sea alive with silver.” In “The Small Hurtling Bodies” readers
are made aware of the dangers in the conflict between nature and
humans:
. . . they hurled themselves
toward the light, their wings,
their bright bodies flung
through glass, flung at the
beacon meant as warning,
flung at the source itself until
feathers and smashed glass
sprayed out north, east, south,
west.
Yet, in “Brief Encounter” the blending of human and
nature contributes to a moment of reflection: “How easily we slid
through waters too slick / with swirls of reflected light / to give
back our faces.” And in the lovely “Couplets by the Cove after a
Hard Year,” the union of nature and human opens an opportunity for
mending:
Below my rock, the water laps
in—gentle as hands
on a breast—bits of foam, blades
of sunlight.
Dried leaves, blood brown, mend
the fractures
between the boulders.
Waves’ gravely speech.
There is healing here: poultice
of salt, bandage of moss,
the little enduring hips of the
beach roses.
Impressively, Patricia Fargnoli surprises the reader
with the multitude of emotions evoked by encounters with nature: joy,
serenity, contemplation, danger, violence, awe, etc. The variety
of incidents in nature and varied responses to them prevent
predictability or boredom; instead, they preserve and present the
possibilities of a fresh glimpse at the relationships between one’s
self and one’s surroundings each time a new line is read.
In poems that serve as an extended metaphor for the
trespassing upon nature by humans, and the intrusion into wilderness by
civilization, Fargnoli’s poetry reminds the reader of classic Bishop
poems such as “The Moose,” “The Armadillo,” or “The Fish.” “First
Night at The Frost Place” begins with the introduction of an unexpected
visitor: “The bat veered erratically over us / on that first
nervous night.” While the twelve writers continue to eat dinner
(“pass the good food, / continued to reach tentatively, / stranger to
stranger”) the speaker is ever-conscious of the bat flying overhead, in
and out of the shadows, “so dark, it seemed / snipped from the burlap
of shadow / high in the rafters above our candlelight.”
Throughout the poem, the “frantic silhouette” and tentative movements
of nature’s intruder mirror the anxiety of the speaker among strangers,
as the poem closes:
And, for all that
society, I
might have missed it entirely—
so far above us it fluttered.
Seen/unseen. Seen/unseen.
The metaphor of natural uneasiness exhibited by the
poet’s speaker reappears in “Evidence” (a terrific, if not quietly
terrifying, poem that also hints at the influence of Robert Frost,
another poet for whom the New England landscape mattered mightily),
where the boundary between wilderness and civilization is kept in mind
for fear of becoming lost outside one’s environment:
I walked carefully, and as far in
as I dared,
trying to keep sight of the road
and the field.
But the forest drew me into its
vast density.
I lost the road, the field, and
all sense of direction.
By the final lines of this poem, the speaker is
immersed in nature — the forest, the falling rain — and if not
completely lost herself, at least alert to something becoming lost,
leaving only evidence of its previous presence.
I turned in a full circle, and
turned again,
I saw nothing
but I swear I heard some spirit
go away
brushing its sharp antlers
against the trees.
In “The Village” elements of nature
serve as cautionary metaphor. Almost as if in reply to the sound
of a carillon, when its “bell notes bounce against the winter sky,” a
woodpecker taps its own beat on a nearby tree:
A woodpecker raps against the
highest trunk,
and what melted in yesterday’s
rain
has frozen into sheets of ice.
Walking’s treacherous.
The dangers represented by parts of nature — the
cold, the ice, the broken limbs caught in branches overhead — echo the
warnings in the society temporarily left behind by the poem’s speaker:
“The country’s on high alert again.” Nevertheless, this rural
natural landscape is home for the speaker: “Here is the life I
know.” The poem closes with a vivid and ominous image of tension
and foreboding that appears an appropriate commentary on the situation
in nature and, even more suitably, in the civilization to which the
narrator knows she must return:
Above me, in the giant maple,
one branch lies winter-snapped
and ready to fall but for the way
it’s cradled across two other
limbs.
One good wind could bring it down.
“The Undeniable Pressure of Existence” is perhaps
the poem in Duties of the Spirit
that most closely resembles Bishop’s poems about encounters with
nature, conflicts between nature and civilization. This poem
describes a fox caught out of its element and roaming among symbols of
the human environment:
I saw the fox running
by the side of the road
past the turned-away brick faces
of the condominiums
past the Citco gas station with
its line of cars and trucks
and he ran, limping, gaunt,
matted dull haired
past Jim’s Pizza, past the
Wash-O-Mat
past the Thai Garden, his sides
heaving like bellows
and he kept running to where the
interstate
crossed the state road and he
reached it and ran on. . .
The speaker reacts with frustration, helplessness,
and sorrow: “I watched him / helpless to do anything to help him,
certain he was beyond / any aid, any desire to save him...
.” One is tempted to also remember the response by the
narrator in William Stafford’s “Traveling through the Dark,” perhaps
another influential work for Fargnoli. As in various Bishop poems
or in Stafford’s poem, the speaker indicates a position of
powerlessness, incapable of any action that would alter the outcome,
nearly resigned to the consequences of various invasions of society on
natural landscapes — the many extended highways and suburban malls or
expanding housing developments (“the perfect / rows of split-levels,
their identical driveways / their brookless and forestless yards”)
slowly encroaching upon the habitat of nature’s creatures. The
speaker characterizes the fox as “out of his element, sick, panting,
starving, / his eyes fixed on some point ahead of him.” How does
one interpret that gaze: what might that point of focus be?
Fargnoli’s narrator suggests the animal is staring ahead, seeking “some
possible salvation / in all this hopelessness, that only he could
see.” Such a final line implies the speaker cannot
share the suspicion that a salvation exists anywhere ahead.
Instead, Fargnoli emphasizes the far more limited vision of humans,
just as she does in “Small Wisdoms”: “The stars continue as far as we
know, / as far as we can see, and as far as we can’t.”
As in Bishop’s works, an elegiac tone filters
through much of Fargnoli’s poetry, and in this case it applies to her
sorrow over the steady loss of natural settings crowded out by
suburban sprawl and the accompanying rapid rate of new construction of
highways with roadside shopping malls. However, Bishop’s poetry
also contains an ongoing concern with vulnerability and a fear of
losing those closest to her. Similarly, the sense of an overall
elegiac theme in Fargnoli’s poetry extends to mourning the absence of
loved ones lost to death or the increasing importance of acknowledging
one’s own mortality as aging occurs. Often, Fargnoli combines her
considerable descriptive gift, especially in communicating the
transition of seasons and the progression of changes during the natural
life-to-death cycles of time, with a poignant meditative note on
personal vulnerability and sadness in the aging process. In
“Talking to
Myself in This Late Year,” Fargnoli records:
Even in the second week of
September, the sea
enamels itself with a brilliance
that comes
from the start of cold weather.
Where did youth go?
Not to mention marriage and
motherhood.
She reports an awareness of death and its influence
on her has been consistent for many years: “When my parents died, / the
aunts pretended nothing had happened. / What could not be spoken / was
held in the muscles and flesh of my body” [“If Too Much Has
Happened”]. Readers discover more of Fargnoli’s meditation on the
temporality of life in “The Last Day,” where an April morning is
perfectly pictured (“the sun has risen / to vibrate three inches above
the mountain / and light shimmies along three wires looped / from the
tall trunk of the pine to the house”). Nevertheless, while “one
bird sings the sweetest notes into being,” Fargnoli questions and
laments the fleeting passage of time: “Stalks are rising — exploding in
yellow / in last year’s garden and one ladybug climbs / the screen — as
if it had all the time in the world.”
“Arguing Life for Life” is a remarkable poem that
draws upon Fargnoli’s professional background as a psychotherapist and
begins with the following startling lines: “Today in my office someone
wanted to die / and I said No.”
The piece transforms into a
self-examination as the speaker confronts her own concern and
consternation about mortality, closing with two moving stanzas:
I leaned back, let my hands fall;
both of us were tired of pain
and loss tallied week after week.
He didn’t know how sometimes I
stand
at my bedroom window looking out
where the steeple lifts over the
town,
wondering what is left to tether
me to the earth.
We sat a long time in silence.
Fortunately for readers, Fargnoli’s frequent times
in silence allow for moments of contemplation and writing on important
issues of life and death, joy and sorrow, contributions and loss,
nature and the natural flow of living a life filled with a large
spirit. In the title poem of this collection, Fargnoli remarks
upon Thorton Wilder’s “duties of the spirit.” According to
Wilder, the first duty is “joy” and the second is “serenity.”
Fargnoli suggests the third duty must be “grief,” which “comes bending
on his walking stick / holding a trowel to dig where the loves have
gone.”
However, Fargnoli concludes the poem not with a
final note of sadness, but with another small wisdom that reaffirms the
value of living despite the temporality of life or happiness and the
eventual stage of grief, reminding readers: “the first is slippery
joy.” Consequently, Fargnoli’s mature poetry provides readers
with
another source of just such a spirit of joy in living and a small
wisdom of the ages that appears to advise grasping life to the fullest
extent while we can with an awareness of the natural beauty around us,
and she presents readers with poems that counsel a total appreciation
for the people and places we experience in the brief time we are
granted.
* * * * *
A
NECESSARY WORLD: B.H.
FAIRCHILD'S LOCAL KNOWLEDGE
“I recall being out on oil rigs, on
various jobs, looking out
across the barren country
treeless from horizon to horizon,
listening to the chains
beating against the derrick
in the ceaseless wind, and
waiting, waiting for life
to come to some kind of
point. But it only seemed
to come to a point on the
printed page, and so I lived,
when I could, among books,
and words filled up
the empty horizon and made
for me a necessary world.”
—B.H. Fairchild, “Afterword:
Lathework”
A decade ago, when B.H. Fairchild’s book
of poems, The Art of the Lathe,
won the 1996 Capricorn Poetry Award, followed by the 1997 Beatrice
Hawley Award, and was released by Alice James Books, many casual
readers previously unfamiliar with Fairchild’s work were stunned to
come upon such powerful poetry. The collection garnered a number
of admiring reviews, and it received widespread recognition as the
volume was named a National Book Award finalist. The book won
various honors, including the Kingsley Tufts Poetry Award and the
William Carlos Williams Award. All of this attention only served
to prepare readers for the numerous accolades accompanying his most
formidable collection of poetry, Early
Occult Memory Systems of the Lower Midwest, released by Norton
in 2003 and winner of the National Book Critics Circle Award.
Contributing to the surprise for those that were
just discovering his poetry in The
Art of the Lathe, some readers were astonished by the
realization that Fairchild was not another typical youthful writer
suddenly becoming well known, flourishing for the first time.
Indeed, this poet, born in 1942, had previously published a couple of
other collections: The Arrival of
the Future (Swallow’s Tale Press, 1985) and Local Knowledge (Quarterly Review
of Literature, 1991). However, soon after its publication of The Arrival of the Future,
Swallow’s Tale Press had closed up shop. Additionally, Local Knowledge was released as
only one collection in a multi-volume single-book format as part of a
series experiment established by poet and editor Ted Weiss at Quarterly Review of Literature.
Included within the covers containing Local
Knowledge were also the volumes of four other poets: Bruce
Bond, Judith Kroll, Garaldine C. Little, and Jean Nordhaus. This
book was soon out of circulation. Consequently, for years both of
Fairchild’s early collections were unavailable to most readers.
Indeed, most people reading The Art of the Lathe were likely
unaware that a number of the poems included in that remarkable
publication first appeared in one or the other of Fairchild’s two
previous volumes. Therefore, in some ways, readers now may view The Art of the Lathe as a
compilation of poems spanning many years of writing. On the other
hand, they may consider it as merely a further continuation and
expansion of an endeavor to explore specific themes, locales, or
personae started by Fairchild in his earlier pair of books. B.H.
Fairchild seems to invite each perspective. His reprinting of
poems from one collection in another suggests Fairchild regards the
books as connected to one another. This attitude would complement
the position taken by Walt Whitman, prominent among Fairchild’s
ancestral poetic influences, who repeatedly enlarged and amended Leaves of Grass throughout his
lifetime. In addition, although there certainly have been some
formal variations and more ambitious poems at times in his later work,
the dominant distinctive content and impressive characteristics of
Fairchild’s poetry have remained reliably the same throughout the last
twenty years.
Perhaps the fact that Fairchild’s book publications
and public recognition have come at an age later than that for many
other contemporary poets promotes a unified appearance to his
poetry. Rather than witnessing the uneven early attempts at
achieving a personal style or the growing pains displayed by younger
poets developing an individual voice — sometimes stumbling or following
false paths along the way — most readers have encountered Fairchild’s
poetry with its mature narrative voice and established poetic
presentation already firmly in place. His work always seems to
exhibit the intelligence, experience, and carefully controlled
craftsmanship usually accomplished by an artist’s gradual evolution
over a sustained period of time, attained after a multitude of efforts
complete with abundant examples of trial and error. Fairchild’s first
book was released when he was 43 years old and his first widely
available solo volume only reached readers when he was about 55 years
old. Like Robert Frost, whose first publication came at the age
of 39, and Wallace Stevens, whose first book was published when he was
44, Fairchild has appeared to enter the consciousness of poetry readers
with a fully developed and consistently persuasive poetic manner.
Even today — after the recently reissued editions of
The Arrival of the Future
(Alice James Books, 2000) and now of Local
Knowledge (W.W. Norton, 2005), released to re-introduce readers
to Fairchild’s previous volumes and, perhaps, to ride the waves of
acclaim greeting Fairchild’s two latest collections — evidence offered
by the early poems only serves to support those critics who have spoken
loudly and laudably of his compelling lyric narrative renditions of
everyday existence in middle America. The poetry in these two
early books examines closely the daily lives, filled with difficulties
and delights, of those various friends, family, co-workers, and
community members Fairchild remembers from his boyhood years and growth
to adulthood in the plains towns of Kansas, the rural settings of
Oklahoma, and the barren landscape of west Texas.
In an interview with Chad Davidson that appeared in
the
February, 2005 issue of The Writer's
Chronicle, Fairchild discusses how he has never been
"self-conscious" about his poetic development, but he does concede: "I
think that if my skills have improved, that improvement is most clearly
demonstrated in my second book, Local
Knowledge. The poems there seem to me more imaginatively
conceived, less predictable in their approach to certain kinds of
subject matter, and the language seems more adventurous." In one
piece
after another, Fairchild profiles people engaged in moments of private
pain or pleasure, intimate triumphs or tragedies, and coping with grief
or personal disappointments in their homes, on the farmlands, at the
machine shops, or among the oil rigs. In his poems, Fairchild
revisits the locations and vocations that influenced his formative
years, and through intricately detailed pictures painted by his memory,
he profiles and preserves the people who helped shape his understanding
of the world around him, as well as his acute awareness of self, the
person he was and the person he would become.
Appropriately, the cover of Fairchild’s book carries
the title Local Knowledge, as
he gives a nod to the importance of comprehending the places and people
of his past. Likewise, it appears fitting that the book closes
with a prose piece, a memoir saluting the influences that inspired his
poetic voice: “The words came early and in different ways: whole days
spent in bed with bronchitis while words floated disembodied from
radio
dramas in another room where my mother was ironing, late nights at
family reunions when booze had loosened the tongues of my usually
silent father and his brothers so that they begin to tell the stories
about growing up in Oklahoma that I never tired of hearing, afternoons
with my father at oil rigs where I would listen to the roughnecks
cursing each other in that wonderfully inventive way that seemed to
make an art of swearing.” Complementing the vocal entertainment
of the local language and placing the components of rural America in
perspective, or at least presenting a means of mental or emotional
escape, Fairchild also acknowledges the crucial contribution of the
written word: “Growing up in that little town in the heart of the dust
bowl, I do not know how I could have survived without the words of the
printed page, of books.”
In fact, even as one is drawn to the machine shop
workers and oil rig repairmen in Fairchild’s poetry, their weary
workdays and plain pursuits of pleasure, there is an ever-present
comprehension that the narrator or poet is someone well-versed in the
workings of the world beyond the fairly bare settings enveloping these
figures. Fairchild explains: “It was rather bleak, surrounded by
wheat and maize fields, with few trees. I recall being out on oil
rigs, on various jobs, looking out across the barren country treeless
from horizon to horizon, listening to the chains beating against the
derrick in the ceaseless wind, and waiting, waiting for life to come to
some kind of point. But it only seemed to come to a point on the
printed page, and so I lived, when I could, among books, and words
filled up the empty horizon and made for me a necessary world.”
Fairchild may have found a life for himself in the
books he read when he was younger, still dreaming of driving away to a
new beginning; however, in Local
Knowledge he now seems driven to the task of bringing to life
those he knew so well back then. His words fill empty pages with
a necessity to describe and trace the lives of others with whom he once
shared the landscapes of Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas. In “West
Texas” Fairchild pauses on the shoulder of a highway to drink a cup of
coffee while driving with his wife and children, a new day opening in
the sky behind them:
My red Ford running to rust idles
along the roadside, one headlight
swinging out across the plains,
the other blind. In the
rear window
dawn light spills over my children
sprawling tangled in the backseat
beneath an army blanket. My
wife
sleeps in front where the radio
loses
itself in static, and even Del Rio
is a distant shout.
“From rig to rig” he travels “every few months,” and
the contours of the countryside continue in a predictable pattern: “the
road looming toward more sky, / bunchgrass, sometimes a stooped, /
ragged clump of trees. Always / a thin curtain of dust in the
air.” While the others sleep, this rugged landscape and an
ominous environment remind the speaker of individuals from his past,
particularly his
father:
Coffee sours through the night,
and I toss the grounds like seeds
from another country over the dry
shoulder. Driving high and
sleepless,
I dream awake: faces like strange
gray flowers form and vanish,
my father kneeling in the road… .
The voice of the poet exposes knowledge of place,
and of the people associated with this region, but it also shows a
sense of authority, a tone spoken out of experience. Fairchild’s
poems often appear presented to readers as shared wisdom offered by a
speaker who has witnessed individuals in difficult conditions or been
tested by days,
if not decades, of hardship, and endured. “The Doppler Effect”
opens with a description of such an atmosphere:
When I would go into bars in
those days
the hard round faces would turn
to speak something like loneliness
but deeper, the rain spilling
into gutters
or the sound of a car pulling away
in a moment of sleeplessness just
before dawn… .
Yet, in Fairchild’s poetry there almost always seems
to be a direction forward that proposes the possibility of hope to
individuals caught in the actions recounted, whether or not they take
advantage of the exit afforded them. Just as “West Texas” closes
with images of moving forward, the freedom of a bird soaring ahead (“My
one headlight / dims in the morning light. The other / mirrors
back the road, the whitening / sky. Far ahead a hawk is sweeping
/ into view on wide, black wings.”), “The Doppler Effect” ends with an
image of sunlight as bright as fire when one of the bar’s patrons opens
a door to leave:
… the door would turn to a yellow
square
so sudden and full of fire
that our eyes would daze and we
would
stare into the long mirrors for
hours
and speak shrewdly of that
pulling away,
that going toward
something.
A choreographer combines the images of birds and
fire as he tells of his childhood days and a desire to leave Nebraska,
where he “learned dance and guilt” from his mother, in “There Is
Constant Movement in My Head,” a sestina that effectively employs the
repetition of the form:
I was a wild bird
crashing into walls, calming down
only to dance. When
Tallchief came down
from New York, a dream flew into
my head:
to be six feet tall, to dance the
Firebird
all in black and red, to shock
Nebraska… .
The speaker is influenced by the migrations of
“sandhill cranes that crossed Nebraska / each fall: sluggish
great-winged birds // lumbering from our pond, the air bird- / heavy
with cries and thrumming.” By the final lines of the poem, “the
dancers are birds,” and the images remain with the speaker, even
as he leaves: “They were all in my head when I left Nebraska.”
Similarly, Fairchild retains in his memory images of
those decades
he found himself caught in the core of the nation's heartland and also
found his fondness for the persuasive force of the written word.
Few recent poets have been quite as successful in their depictions of
rural America and its inhabitants. Fairchild's descriptions are
often as captivating and as haunting as old black-and-white photographs
or grainy documentary footage chronicling the hard existence of workers
on farms, in mills, or at their machines in shops across the country's
central sections. Nevertheless, the pictures readers receive in
Fairchild's poetry are difficult to categorize because, even in their
stark presentations, Fairchild places enough details to entice one into
gathering a feeling of attraction, if not attachment, much the way one
might be drawn to the odd sight of an interestingly scarred antique
dresser, its
rich wood distressed, marked and marred by evidence of years of
personal use, and now deemed worthy of special notice.
In "The Last Days" Fairchild's speaker offers
readers an invitation to witness this world as he has seen it:
Out here, where the
high wires pitch and whine
and bluestem rakes the tops of my
wrists,
the sky seems to worry itself
into dusk,
clouds thinning into mare's tails,
a rasp of grackles keening into
the west wind,
tumbleweeds that lunge, then hang
on the rusted barbs of hard,
angry possession.
In Fairchild's best descriptive passages
various elements of nature are compared in their physical presence or
combined in the mind of the speaker ("clouds thinning into mare's
tails"). Often, humans and natural
objects touch one another through physical contact ("bluestem rakes the
top of my wrists") or with emotional projection through personification
("the sky seems to worry itself into dusk"). All the components
of the poem's imagery contribute to a sense of the speaker's attitude
and develop a mood looming over every action that occurs ("grackles
keening into the west wind" and "rusted barbs of hard, angry
possession"). Later in the same poem, the speaker further
positions himself among characteristic features of the countryside, and
again emphasizes a sense of emotional identification with his
surroundings:
For hours I have
walked the fences
of these separate fields where
the dying light
grows long and mottled over
bunches
of shorn maize stalks and rotted
fenceposts,
where last night's dream comes
flashing back
like the sputtering red lights of
the town's
last elevator warning off low
flights... .
The dream he recalls in this environment
reveals his deceased grandmother pleading to him, "release the dead, let them rise up
/ and walk the bankrupt fields and
turn them / back to
worldliness, the way we found them." For Fairchild, the
hard, dark landscape creates an apt atmosphere for remembering those
souls who once inhabited it. His poetry serves as an elegiac
salute to figures now absent, even as it embraces them and brings them
to life with its lyrical language.
Indeed, an image of a figure more noticeable for its
absence occupies center stage in the impressively powerful piece that
opens this book, a compelling poem that delivers an emotional blow and
sets
the tone for much of what awaits readers in the poetry of following
pages. In the interview with Chad Davidson, Fairchild comments
about the
possibility of a
"breakthrough" poem in his writing over the years: there have been "a
few poems where I felt that, perhaps, at least in my own eyes, I had
enlarged the scope of my abilities. That happened in the poem,
'In Czechoslovakia,' from the second book, Local Knowledge, where I had two
narrative lines that I was trying to weave together." "In
Czechoslovakia" explores an incident experienced in 1968 about which
Fairchild narrates in the book's afterword:
. . . as a young man I happened to be sitting alone
in a movie theater
waiting for the darkness, like
sleep, to descend, and I noticed several
rows in front a woman speaking to
someone hidden in the seat beside
her. The someone was
apparently her child, for she doted on it, smiling
expressively, occasionally
laughing, talking to it, reaching over to smooth
its dress or collar. She
even went to the concession stand and brought
back a box of popcorn for
it. After the movie started, this constant yet
unobtrusive stream of maternal
affection continued, and when the movie
ended, I waited to see what the
child looked like. The mother rose and
walked out with her hand
outstretched as if the child hidden behind the
row of seats were following at
arm's length, but when they reached the
aisle, the mother's hand was
holding nothing at all. There was no child.
And the woman walked up the aisle
and out of the theater with her hand
held out to nothing, occasionally
looking down and speaking to the child
she only imagined.
In the poem Fairchild explains the plot
of the World War II movie playing on the screen, The Shop on Main Street, and offers
information about
its main character, a Jewish widow "who is old / and deaf and has the
eyes of a feverish child. / She smiles in luminous gratitude for almost
anything— / the empty button boxes, a photo of her lost daughter...
." Finally, in the film a man, whom the widow trusts as someone
who "has come to help her," betrays her. Secretly working for the
authorities as an Aryan Controller, he instructs the widow she must
board one of the trucks collecting Jews or he will suffer
consequences:
. . . he will be
arrested as a collaborator, and as he
stands there pleading, going
crazy in her husband's suit
which she has given to
him, her eyes widen
like opened fists and she knows
now and begins
to shout, pogrom, pogrom, with her hands
trembling
like moths around her face, and
when he panics
and hurls her into the closet to
hide her, she falls
and oh Jesus he has killed her
and he cries out... .
At this moment silence in the movie
theater is also shattered because "the woman in the front row / is
shouting at the child, it's misbehaved in some way." Gradually,
the narratives of the two women — one in the scene in World War II
Czechoslovakia and the other in an American movie theater decades later
— become linked in the mind of the speaker, who had been "stunned" by
the events in the fictional story of the cinema and suddenly must
confront the present image of a woman walking alone down the theater
aisle, her hand guiding a child who does not exist: "And you see it,
though you don't want to... ." He notices the woman's facial
expression: "she has this smile / of adoration, this lacemaker's gaze
of contentment, / she is perfectly
happy, and she walks on out... ." The speaker can only
follow her out among other passers-by on the street, and he thinks to
himself, though by now the poem has shifted from first person to second
person, as he positions the reader in his shoes contemplating leaving
the theater:
. . . where you will
have to walk up and down
as if you were on a boulevard in
Czechoslovakia
watching the endless cortege of
gray trucks
rumble by in splendid alignment
as you go on thinking
and breathing as usual, wreathed
in your own human skin.
One manner of engaging B.H. Fairchild's
poetry is exemplified by this early poem. In an interview with
Paul Mariani that appeared in the Fall, 2005 issue of Image, Fairchild analyzes an
approach to writing poetry he has adopted: "It seems obvious that most
poems these days are lyric/narrative hybrids. I think of pure
lyric as being a vertical movement within a moment of time — sometimes
an infinitely small moment — and pure narrative as being a horizontal
movement in time... . In fact, I think a narrative poem always
has to be a hybrid, even though it's closer to the horizontal axis,
because a poem must have at least some lyric depth. Beginning as
far back as 'In Czechoslovakia' in my second book, Local Knowledge, I became
interested in this problem of writing a narrative that sustains
momentum without sacrificing lyric depth." Perhaps a factor
leading toward much of the admiration for Fairchild's poetry is his
unerring ear for lyric language even when projecting a narrative
forward or describing materials some, at first, might normally consider
unpoetic. In his interview with Mariani, Fairchild reveals a few
origins and influences contributing to his mix of lyrical and
narrative, always extracting eloquent poetry from less obviously
elegant
sources of inspiration: "As I began to write poems myself, Bill
Stafford, James Wright, and Richard Hugo became very important to me
because they validated my subject matter. I had grown up in small
towns in the oil fields, and I had thought poems needed to be about
Grecian urns and unrequited love and nightingales. Those three
poets made it immediately clear that I could write about my own
experiences."
Another prominent influence on Fairchild's attitude
toward art and craftmanship arose when he was a boy witnessing his
father and other machine shop employees display great care and pride in
their work. Fairchild tells Mariani, "among my earliest memories
is standing by my father as he operated a lathe. He was a
perfectionist and so introduced me to the idea of craft, 'a small thing
done well.' The odd fact that I fell in love with craft itself
before I ever came to poetry has had a huge influence on the way I
think about poetry. I vividly remember how he would point out
something another machinist had done as 'good work,' clearly the
highest kind of praise, and how disdainfully he would refer to other
work as 'sloppy.' It was a moral distinction as much as an
aesthetic one and made a deep impression on me." Consequently,
the afterword to Local Knowledge,
bearing the title "Lathework," details this influence even further:
"The first image, I was to discover, holds the model for everything I
have written, especially poems: lathework. In machine shops in
Houston, Lubbock, Midland, and Snyder, Texas, I would as a boy stand on
the wooden ramp next to my father and watch his hands move gracefully
and efficiently over the lathe, maneuvering the levers and rotary
handles and making the bit move in and out, back and forth, as the huge
chuck spun a section of drill pipe in its iron grip." Indeed, the
younger Fairchild developed a sense of reverence for the perfectionism
exhibited by his father and the other men he watched work those
machines.
Repeatedly, Fairchild has returned in his poetry to
actions observed in the machine shops. In "Toban's
Precision Machine Shop" Fairchild speaks of the shop's "spiritual"
atmosphere, attentive to the search for "perfection," and the
"possibility" of aesthetic pleasure he recognized as evident in the
tools of the trade:
. . . It is a shop
so old the lathes are driven by
leather belts
descending like some spiritual
harness
from a long shaft beneath the tin
roof's peak.
Such emptiness.
Such a large and palpable
sculpture of disuse: lathes
leaning against
their leather straps, grinding
wheels motionless
above mounds of iron
filings. Tools lie lead-
heavy along the backs of steel
workbenches,
burnished where the morning light
leaks through
and lifts them up. Calipers
and honing cloths
hang suspended in someone's dream
of perfection.
There are times when
the sun lingers over
the green plastic panels on the
roof, and light
seems to rise from the floor,
seems to lift lathes
and floor at once, and something
announces itself:
not beauty, but rather its
possibility... .
Throughout his poetry, readers discern
not only Fairchild's respect for the craftsmanship of the workers he
watched in the machine shops, but often a deep regard for the
intelligence and character of the individuals as well.
Fairchild's personae are people who do not support the easy
stereotyping
or dismissal by others that might exist elsewhere. In the closing
stanza of the poem, readers see Toban, the shop owner, as he "sits in
his office among his books / with music settling down on his shoulders
/ like a warm shawl. He replaces the Mahler / with Schubert, the
B-flat sonata, and sends it / unravelling toward me, turning the sound
/ far above the cluttered silence of the lathes." Fairchild makes
note of this poem, and his attempt to counter others' stereotypical
depictions
of characters like those in his poems, in his conversation with
Mariani:
I resent the way
blue-collar labor is often stereotyped as being
utterly divorced from high
culture, as if it were performed only
by men and women whose lives are
a cycle of beer drinking,
Monday night football, and
NASCAR, and who have never
read or wanted to read The Brothers Karamazov or Anna Karenina.
I have a cousin, for instance,
who is a machinist and comes in
and sets the parameters on the
lathe (they're computerized now),
then leans back and reads
Heidegger. Maybe that's exceptional,
but I also have a poem, "Toban's
Precision Machine Shop," that
resulted from walking into a very
old shop in San Bernardino
(so old the lathes were driven by
belts connected to an overhead
shaft) where a Mahler symphony
was flooding the air.
Fairchild further praises the men in his
memory who now populate his poetry: "The men in those shops, including
my father, were highly skilled laborers who performed tasks whose
intellectual complexity was at least equal to if not more demanding
than those performed by academic intellectuals." Anyone
encountering the poetry of this early volume — the priority of
craftsmanship and artwork as recounted through recollections from
childhood or adolescence — would not be surprised to find the titles of
Fairchild's follow-up collections, The
Art of the Lathe and Early
Occult Memories of the Lower Midwest.
In recent years Fairchild has been especially
concerned about the deterioration of towns he once knew so well.
He begins his interview with Chad Davidson by voicing consternation
over "the fact that small towns in rural areas in the United States —
though we are concentrating on the Midwest, where I'm from — are
declining at an alarming rate." Fairchild divulges that he is
presently working on a "poetry/photography project" to bring attention
to the current conditions he sees in the region remembered throughout
his poetry: "I'm groping with radical alterations in both space and
time: empty downtowns, empty stores, empty streets, commercial life
moving out of town rather than occurring at the center of the
community. Time is more linear now than cyclical as it was when
the town lived according to the same planting and harvesting cycles as
the small farmers, when time for the trades people was a relatively
slow work week punctuated by enormously busy Saturdays... ."
However, even in this early book now reissued, Fairchild's poetry has
suggested the end of an era — like the belt-driven, hand-adjusted
lathes that have given way to computerized machines — that might only
be preserved in memories and the art of his poetry. In "The
Structures of Everyday Life" Fairchild hints at the way shop workers
once ended their days:
In the shop's nave,
where the wind bangs sheets
of tin against iron beams, barn
sparrows
quarrel like old lovers. At
five o'clock
the lathes wind down from their
long flight.
Burnt coils of steel loom from
collecting bins.
In the washroom
photographs of wives and lovers
look down on the backs of men
pale as shells.
Brown wrists and black hands
lather and shine
in the light of one dim lamp, and
blue shirts
hang like the stilled hands of a
deaf-mute.
Once again, through
his use of the word "nave," Fairchild indicates the reverence he
maintains for the work performed by the craftsmen in those shops still
vivid in his memory. This veneration that fills his poetry is
further demonstrated in the poem's final lines as the men "kneel" to
tie their shoes and exit at the end of a workday, but also might be
viewed as leaving behind them an era that no longer exists except now
in Fairchild's memory and art:
Like eremites at
prayer, the men kneel to lace
their shoes, touching the worn
heels of a life.
When they leave, the faces on the
locker doors
turn back to darkness, each man
shoulders the sun,
carries it through the fields,
the lighted streets.
The closing image of the sun over the
men's shoulders and the lighted streets ahead may appear reminiscent of
the image previously presented in "West Texas," where sunlight spilled
through the rear window of an automobile, and the red Ford's headlights
aimed at the road
ahead. As with the reprinting of poems from one volume to
another, recurring images and repetition of settings in Fairchild's
work serve to thread together individual poems, creating a sense of
connection or cumulative effect. For instance, "West Texas" opens
with the line, "My red Ford running to rust idles," similar to the
first image in the book's title poem, "Local Knowledge": "A rusted-out
Ford Fairlane with red hubcaps." Likewise, "Local Knowledge"
continues with the car heaving "a swirl of dust," while "Work" speaks
of light that "lifts dust / in swirls." Moreover, the second
stanza of "Local Knowledge" begins, "Rows of drill collars stand in
racks and howl / in the blunt wind." This is not too different
from the start of the opening stanza of "Work": "Drill collars lie on
racks and howl / in the blunt wind." Throughout Local Knowledge, and much of the
poetry in Fairchild's other collections, the lyrical language of the
poet's distinctive voice echoes for readers, as if we, too, are
returning to the scenes that replay themselves again and again in
Fairchild's memories.
Reviving incidents and individuals
remembered after years of absence appears to be a vital purpose for
Fairchild as he writes poetry. In "Speaking the Names," one of
the poems later reprinted in The Art
of the Lathe, Fairchild revisits land where an abandoned
farmhouse and vacant barn stand as monuments to those who no longer
linger except in his memory: "Behind me is a house without
people. And so, for my sake / I bring them back, watching the
quick cloud of vapor that blooms / and vanishes with each syllable: O.T. and Nellie Swearingen, / their
children, Locie, Dorrel, Deanie,
Bill, / and the late Vinna
Adams, whose name I speak into the bright and final air."
These figures represent an absence haunting Fairchild, staying with him
over the decades almost in a way that the absent child accompanied the
woman at the movie theater of "In Czechoslovakia." Speaking in
his afterword to Local Knowledge
about his reaction to that woman and her imaginary child, Fairchild
believes, "it is the fact of absence in the scene that will not let me
forget it: the absence beneath the mother's hand as she walked out of
the theater, the absence of apparent meaning, the absence of a real
rather than an imagined life, absences like so many lighted windows as
you walk through a strange city, wanting to fill them with imaginary
lives and words and stories."
Fairchild fills the absences he discovers in his
life, and those stolen moments attached to his personal history, with
rich images and
compelling characters, shafts of bright light illuminating a darkened
landscape or sifting through shadows inside a dusty machine shop.
His
vocabulary is consistent and convincing, with words whose lyricism
evokes an appreciation for the possibility of beauty even in brutal
conditions and amid stark surroundings.
This reissue of Local
Knowledge gives readers a road map with directions leading
straight to the great poems included in Fairchild's more recent and
more familiar books, particularly those numerous later works that have
received much deserved attention and acclaim, poems like "Beauty,"
"Body and Soul," "The Art of the Lathe," "Early Occult Memory Systems
of the Lower Midwest," "The Blue Buick: A Narrative," "The Memory of a
Possible Future," and "The Memory Palace." At its best,
Fairchild's poetry acts as a lasting testimony to the significance of
those lost lives and livelihoods, the loves and labors, he desires to
celebrate, or at least to preserve, in his lyrical lines. It is a
wistful, yet wishful poetry, filled with a longing to present and
preserve parts of a past (and its participants) that have been blown
away as if with the churning wind turning through the town in "Dust
Storm." In his work, preservation in the poet's memory allows a
second chance, perhaps a last opportunity, for
a recovery of those now absent, a perseverance of spirit, a persistence
in spite of difficulties and obstacles, a continuance toward a state of
restoration, and sometimes even arrival at an act of redemption.
Fargnoli, Patricia. Duties
of the
Spirit. Dorset, Vermont: Tupelo Press, 2005. ISBN:
1-932195-21-1 $16.95
Fairchild, B.H.. Local
Knowledge. New York, New York: W.W. Norton & Company,
2005. ISBN: 0-393-3221-1 $13.95
© by Edward Byrne
|